Tuesday, November 25, 2014

Troubling Reading for Troubled Kids

Older Daughter is now back at the local public high school for junior year (long story).  I've been helping her write an essay on "Death of a Salesman" for English class.  True confession:  I haven't actually read "Death of a Salesman", but I skimmed the wikipedia article, from which I deduce that "D of a S" is one bleak, dismal bummer of a play.

Here's a partial list of OD's assigned reading at school:  Into the Wild (a misguided dreamer starves to death alone in Alaska), Catcher in the Rye (a depressed prep-school kid), I Know Why the Caged Bird Sings (racism and child rape), Persepolis (a girl growing up in Iran learns that her grandfather was imprisoned and tortured by the Shah; the revolution is not an improvement), Night (a horrific first-person account of the Holocaust), and Romeo and Juliet (two teenagers fall in love and wind up committing suicide). Notice a pattern?

Depressed people are commonly advised to avoid "ruminating", or chewing over depressive thoughts.  I think this is good advice.  In an ideal world OD should be avoiding depressing reading, but that's just not possible when she's going to high school.

Why is high school English reading such a downer? I can think of a couple of reasons (both idiotic, but that's par for the course):

1.)  Dismal = Deep.  A light-hearted or happy book can't be an Important Work of Literature. If we're going to be taken seriously, we must be seen to suffer.  (This also happens in art education, where making the students suffer proves the seriousness of the course.)

2.)  Since teenagers are often troubled, moody and depressed, and complain that the world is unjust and cruel, it's thought to be appropriate to give them books full of troubled, moody and depressed characters living in an unjust and cruel world.  This is the theory that people can only understand books that relate directly to their own experience -- the old "text-to-self" concept.  Bah, humbug! I say.


  1. I agree as to the reasons , but let's not forget political considerations . I'd put that at number 1 really

    AND I would say generally main stream reading material ,TV video games , even kids books are horror based . What passes for main stream TV actually terrifies me ...walking dead , how to get away with murder. Lost, Dirty little liars , Bates Hotel the prequel , Dexter etc...movies, hunger games? Kids fight to the death for food? It denotes a depraved society when horror and seemingly only such horror is considered main stream and normal

    looking at that school list I'd say Death of a Salesman was the Rebecca of Sunnybrook Farm of the Bunch

    Maybe your family could read something more uplifting together ?

  2. Pakistanvipescorts.com is Escorts Agency We Deals Escorts in Lahore, Fashion Models And Pakistani schools Girls. We Are The Best Escorts Agency in Pakistan or Top Pakistani Call Girls Provider. We have an expansive gathering of Escort Girls. Also, offering you the best female escorts services for hotel or private dating, restrictive girlfriend experience, travel and get-away escorts with beguiling girls.